ROSHAN'S REVIEWS
  • New Reviews
  • About
  • Blog
  • Podcast
  • Must-see Movies
  • Film Diary
  • Contact

13 REASONS WHY (2017-)                                             SEASON 1 EPISODE 1 TV REVIEW

6/17/2017

0 Comments

 
Picture


* 
15, 13 Episodes (Netflix)

Grossly insensitive and stupidly sensationalist.
This controversial Netflix-produced 13-part series centres around Clay Jenson (Dylan Minette) – a socially inept, high-school “geek” who finds himself infatuated with seemingly perfect new girl in class Hannah Baker (Katherine Langford).

Given the opening chapter appears to outrageously re-inforce every teen cliché in the book; naturally Hannah has no mutual feelings for the mild-mannered male protagonist. Of course, this is down to him being a “nerd” and not a “jock”!

“You’ll fill out someday…maybe” is Hannah’s blunt advice to Clay; suggesting any male not built like a brick outerhouse is frankly non-existent in this girl’s eyes.

As for Clay’s mousy shyness around her, Hannah views this as pure jealousy. “Is your dad also thin and nervous?” she bemuses. Call me old-fashioned, but when did a person’s body weight define confidence? Or at least when did we actually believe it truly defined such?

Moreover, does being “thin and nervous” make one less attractive or a horrid person?
The episode flits between two utterly unclarified time frames. One chin-stroking over Clay’s unintentionally creepy attempts at wooing his crush. The other, however, is grotesquely more offensive.

While we viewers are never exactly informed how far along this event takes place, the series’ much discussed central conceit surrounds that of Hannah’s unprecedented suicide.

Yet where one would expect this to provide foundation for a moving deconstruction of teenage mental illness, ’13 Reasons Why’ appears to wave such a subject around as if it’s a badge of honour! Or does it? ...

It’s not long before curious Clay receives a collection of anonymously sent audio cassette tapes fitted through his mailbox. Upon setting ears upon them, it is revealed to be the long lost voice of his deceased dream lover; intent on explaining just what led Hannah Baker to end her own life…

Or should I say – as this pilot seems to flippantly ram in our face – a virtually endless list of blame…

With a title such as “13 Reasons Why” alone threatening to tabloidize its deeply sensitive subject matter, arguably anyone should be wary of Writer Brian Yorkey’s show…
It’s no surprise therefore that – within at least 10 mins – one unreservedly felt his mouth plunging into a pillow; only to prevent himself from vomiting at something so monstrously manipulative.

For whatever you may have been told about the series being a harrowingly “real” eye-opener to the hidden world of cyberbullying, emotional abuse and body shaming, Episode 1 (entitled ‘Tape 1: Side A’) presents no smidgen of evidence regarding that…

Tonally skipping between schmaltzy melodrama, whimsy rom-com and trashy telly thriller, ’13 Reasons Why’ only coffee sips over it’s themes before mindlessly disposing of them as merely plastic pins on a crime map.

Undoubtedly many may argue that teenage suicide exploited as a plot device is no less inconsiderate than every throwaway ‘CSI’ case-of the-week murder streak. A point well made.

Yet in a world where mental health awareness is positively thriving, I can’t help, but find it slightly baffling that so-called "entertainment" like '13 Reasons Why' still exists.

This is essentially a fraudulently mopey exercise in ‘Twilight’ dirge. One that - while force-feeding dreary emo songs, wardrobe wooden acting and fatuously fabulist dialogue down your oesophagus – is unacceptably unconscious of its situation’s severity.

The show clearly aspires to be J.B Priestley’s ‘An Inspector Calls’, but this pilot problematically proves the distinct difference between analysing adolescent angst and deplorably screwing over society.

Unlike Channel 4’s terrific, Maisie Williams-starring ‘Cyberbully’ (2015) which laid out the digital dangers facing 12-18 year old girls with unbiased meditation; ‘13 Reasons Why’ seems duplicitous in its cynical “YOU DID THIS!” finger pointing.

Already, within its first hour, the show has Hannah gloating execrably about her naïve flings with a self-serving frat boy; only to later brutally chastise poor, well-meaning Clay when things go horrendously pear-shaped.

Indeed Hannah’s self-recorded tapes are ravished with bitter contempt for seemingly everyone around her, including those who clearly don’t deserve it.

As Hannah manipulates Clay into uncovering the truths behind her demise, one struggled to contain their inner hostility towards the Writer’s tension-milking treatment of these characters.

Not only does ‘13 Reasons Why’ appear to have an anti-PC checklist caricaturing every high school horror imaginable, but also criminally manages to degrade its core tragedy.

There’s not a drop of sympathy to be found towards a beautiful young woman; brimming with hopes and dreams and heartbreakingly stripped of such. Instead Writer Yorkey does nothing, but belittle her; largely making Hannah out to be a coward and attention-seeker – the exact stigma which mental health activists are passionately fighting hard to bust!


0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Picture

    Meet Roshan Chandy

    Freelance Film Critic and Writer based in Nottingham, UK. Specialises in Science Fiction cinema.

    Roshan's Top 10 Best Films of 2020

    1. Tenet
    2. Clemency
    3. Rocks
    4. Portrait of a Lady on Fire
    5. Mangrove
    6. David Byrne's American Utopia
    7. Never Rarely Sometimes Always
    8. Calm with Horses
    9. Saint Maud
    10. Soul


    Follow Me on Twitter
    ​

    Tweets by chandy_roshan

    Rating System 

    ***** 2 Thumbs Up
    ****  Thumb Up
    *** Waving Thumbs
    **   Thumb Down
    *   2 Thumbs Down
    ​

    Archives

    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    June 2019
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2015

    RSS Feed

    FILM OF THE WEEK
    ​

    Picture

    Soul
    ​(PG, 97 Mins)

    Pixar's latest is a lovely, jazzy look at life, death and the afterlife. Their best film since 'Inside Out' (2015).


    DVD OF THE WEEK
    ​

    Picture

    Relic
    (Blu-ray and DVD)
    (15, 89 Mins)

    Natalie Erika James' real-world horror taps into our fears about ageing and Alzheimer's with spine-tingling and moving results.

    TV MOVIE OF THE WEEK
    ​

    Picture

    Slumdog Millionaire (2009)
    (15, 120 Mins)       
    Weds 20th Jan., 11.20pm, Film4

    Feelgood film or not, Danny Boyle's movie is a fable of Dickensian social realism and escapist dreams.
Proudly powered by Weebly
  • New Reviews
  • About
  • Blog
  • Podcast
  • Must-see Movies
  • Film Diary
  • Contact